JINDALSTEL vs TATASTEEL: Which Is Better on the Numbers?
Jindal Steel Ltd (JINDALSTEL) trades at ₹1042 on a P/E of 26.4, while Tata Steel Ltd (TATASTEEL) trades at ₹184 on a P/E of 20.3. On valuation, Tata Steel Ltd is cheaper on earnings (P/E 20.3 vs 26.4). This is a data comparison, not a recommendation.
JINDALSTEL vs TATASTEEL - full comparison
| Metric | JINDALSTEL | TATASTEEL |
|---|---|---|
| Share price | ₹1,041.9 | ₹184.23 |
| P/E ratio (lower = cheaper) | 26.40 | 20.30 |
| ROE (higher = better) | 8.22% | 11.70% |
| ROCE (higher = better) | 9.70% | 12.50% |
| Dividend yield | 0.19% | 2.17% |
| Annualised return (history) | +4.5% | +7.1% |
| Volatility (lower = steadier) | 29% | 28% |
| 1-year forecast (Monte Carlo median) | ₹1,050 | ₹191.59 |
| Cheapest MTF margin | 23% (Dhan) | 23% (Dhan) |
Forecast as of 24 Jul
How JINDALSTEL and TATASTEEL compare
- On valuation, Tata Steel Ltd is cheaper on earnings (P/E 20.3 vs 26.4).
- On profitability, Tata Steel Ltd earns a higher return on equity (ROE 11.7% vs 8.2%).
- For income, Tata Steel Ltd pays a higher dividend yield (2.17% vs 0.19%).
- On recent momentum, Tata Steel Ltd has the stronger annualised return (+7.1% vs +4.5%).
- On risk, Tata Steel Ltd has been less volatile (annualised volatility 28% vs 29%).
Not investment advice. This page compares publicly available metrics and a statistical forecast for information only. The 1-year forecast is a Monte Carlo projection from historical volatility, not a prediction. Do your own research or consult a SEBI-registered adviser before investing.
More stock comparisons
INFY vs TCSTCS vs WIPROINFY vs WIPROHCLTECH vs TCSHCLTECH vs INFYHCLTECH vs WIPROINFY vs TECHMHDFCBANK vs ICICIBANKHDFCBANK vs SBINICICIBANK vs SBINHDFCBANK vs KOTAKBANKAXISBANK vs ICICIBANKAXISBANK vs SBINAXISBANK vs KOTAKBANKAXISBANK vs HDFCBANKADANIENT vs RELIANCEMARUTI vs TATAMOTORSBAJAJ-AUTO vs HEROMOTOCOEICHERMOT vs TATAMOTORSDRREDDY vs SUNPHARMACIPLA vs SUNPHARMACIPLA vs DRREDDYCIPLA vs DIVISLABJSWSTEEL vs TATASTEEL
Related tools
- JINDALSTEL MTF margins & research
- TATASTEEL MTF margins & research
- Stock screener - filter by P/E, ROE and 30+ metrics
- Stock valuation - estimate intrinsic value
- Nifty PE tracker - market-wide valuation context