Is TATACHEM or TATACONSUM a better buy?

On valuation, Tata Chemicals Ltd is cheaper on earnings (P/E 67.6 vs 72.9). On profitability, Tata Consumer Products Ltd earns a higher return on equity (ROE 7.3% vs 1.3%). For income, Tata Chemicals Ltd pays a higher dividend yield (1.53% vs 0.88%). Neither is universally "better" — it depends on your goals and risk appetite. This is a data comparison, not investment advice.

What is the P/E ratio of TATACHEM vs TATACONSUM?

Tata Chemicals Ltd (TATACHEM) has a P/E of 67.60; Tata Consumer Products Ltd (TATACONSUM) has a P/E of 72.90. A lower P/E means the stock is cheaper relative to earnings.

TATACHEM vs TATACONSUM: Which Is Better on the Numbers?

Tata Chemicals Ltd (TATACHEM) trades at ₹715 on a P/E of 67.6, while Tata Consumer Products Ltd (TATACONSUM) trades at ₹1117 on a P/E of 72.9. On valuation, Tata Chemicals Ltd is cheaper on earnings (P/E 67.6 vs 72.9). This is a data comparison, not a recommendation.

Tata Chemicals Ltd

TATACHEM

₹715.25

MTF & research →Price target →

Tata Consumer Products Ltd

TATACONSUM

₹1,116.9

MTF & research →Price target →

TATACHEM vs TATACONSUM — full comparison

Metric	TATACHEM	TATACONSUM
Share price	₹715.25	₹1,116.9
P/E ratio (lower = cheaper)	67.60	72.90
ROE (higher = better)	1.27%	7.35%
ROCE (higher = better)	3.42%	9.24%
Dividend yield	1.53%	0.88%
Annualised return (history)	-21.3%	-0.7%
Volatility (lower = steadier)	29%	23%
1-year forecast (Monte Carlo median)	₹554.42	₹1,076.63
Cheapest MTF margin	30.02% (Zerodha)	22% (Dhan)

How TATACHEM and TATACONSUM compare

On valuation, Tata Chemicals Ltd is cheaper on earnings (P/E 67.6 vs 72.9).
On profitability, Tata Consumer Products Ltd earns a higher return on equity (ROE 7.3% vs 1.3%).
For income, Tata Chemicals Ltd pays a higher dividend yield (1.53% vs 0.88%).
On recent momentum, Tata Consumer Products Ltd has the stronger annualised return (-0.7% vs -21.3%).
On risk, Tata Consumer Products Ltd has been less volatile (annualised volatility 23% vs 29%).
For margin trading, Tata Consumer Products Ltd has the lower MTF margin requirement (22% via Dhan).

Not investment advice. This page compares publicly available metrics and a statistical forecast for information only. The 1-year forecast is a Monte Carlo projection from historical volatility, not a prediction. Do your own research or consult a SEBI-registered adviser before investing.

More stock comparisons

Related tools

TATACHEM MTF margins & research
TATACONSUM MTF margins & research
Stock screener — filter by P/E, ROE and 30+ metrics
Stock valuation — estimate intrinsic value
Nifty PE tracker — market-wide valuation context