Is TATACONSUM or TATAPOWER a better buy?

On valuation, Tata Power Company Ltd is cheaper on earnings (P/E 34.4 vs 72.9). On profitability, Tata Power Company Ltd earns a higher return on equity (ROE 10.1% vs 7.3%). For income, Tata Consumer Products Ltd pays a higher dividend yield (0.88% vs 0.61%). Neither is universally "better" — it depends on your goals and risk appetite. This is a data comparison, not investment advice.

What is the P/E ratio of TATACONSUM vs TATAPOWER?

Tata Consumer Products Ltd (TATACONSUM) has a P/E of 72.90; Tata Power Company Ltd (TATAPOWER) has a P/E of 34.40. A lower P/E means the stock is cheaper relative to earnings.

TATACONSUM vs TATAPOWER: Which Is Better on the Numbers?

Tata Consumer Products Ltd (TATACONSUM) trades at ₹1117 on a P/E of 72.9, while Tata Power Company Ltd (TATAPOWER) trades at ₹409 on a P/E of 34.4. On valuation, Tata Power Company Ltd is cheaper on earnings (P/E 34.4 vs 72.9). This is a data comparison, not a recommendation.

Tata Consumer Products Ltd

TATACONSUM

₹1,116.9

MTF & research →Price target →

Tata Power Company Ltd

TATAPOWER

₹409.2

MTF & research →Price target →

TATACONSUM vs TATAPOWER — full comparison

Metric	TATACONSUM	TATAPOWER
Share price	₹1,116.9	₹409.2
P/E ratio (lower = cheaper)	72.90	34.40
ROE (higher = better)	7.35%	10.10%
ROCE (higher = better)	9.24%	10.50%
Dividend yield	0.88%	0.61%
Annualised return (history)	-0.7%	-4.6%
Volatility (lower = steadier)	23%	26%
1-year forecast (Monte Carlo median)	₹1,076.63	₹378.07
Cheapest MTF margin	22% (Dhan)	22% (Dhan)

How TATACONSUM and TATAPOWER compare

On valuation, Tata Power Company Ltd is cheaper on earnings (P/E 34.4 vs 72.9).
On profitability, Tata Power Company Ltd earns a higher return on equity (ROE 10.1% vs 7.3%).
For income, Tata Consumer Products Ltd pays a higher dividend yield (0.88% vs 0.61%).
On recent momentum, Tata Consumer Products Ltd has the stronger annualised return (-0.7% vs -4.6%).
On risk, Tata Consumer Products Ltd has been less volatile (annualised volatility 23% vs 26%).

Not investment advice. This page compares publicly available metrics and a statistical forecast for information only. The 1-year forecast is a Monte Carlo projection from historical volatility, not a prediction. Do your own research or consult a SEBI-registered adviser before investing.

More stock comparisons

Related tools

TATACONSUM MTF margins & research
TATAPOWER MTF margins & research
Stock screener — filter by P/E, ROE and 30+ metrics
Stock valuation — estimate intrinsic value
Nifty PE tracker — market-wide valuation context